Friday, July 11, 2008

Avant Gardners: 50 Visionaries of the Contemporary Landscape

This isn't a book for the cottage gardener or the complacent. It is certain to spark a powerful response in many readers – if it has many readers. Conceptual landscape design is not a subject of widespread interest in most gardening circles, certainly not in North America.

Avant Gardeners may delight you, annoy you, frustrate you, spark new insights about gardening and design. I have to confess my prejudice. I appreciate the work of some conceptual landscape designers. I’ve always liked Martha Schwartz’ playful park at Jacob Javits Plaza (we call it “the Federal Building”) in New York City – liked it years before I even knew it was designed by Martha Schwartz – even before I knew Martha Schwartz existed. But I dislike many of the conceptual landscapes in this book.

Admittedly, some are beautiful, or so appropriate to place, I can’t deny their relevance to the urban world: I’m remembering the first landscape in the book, designed by Atelier Big City, a small, mainly concrete park for hanging out and skateboarding under an elevated bridge approach in Montreal that seems a perfect solution for an almost-waste-space. While most conceptual landscapes are urban, some are not. Wigandia, for example, William Martin’s ecologically appropriate garden-cum-artwork on the side of a volcano in Australia is full of plants that thrive in drought, and it stands as a direct, even polemical, criticism of the prevalence of "British style" gardens so inappropriate to Australia, a land of sun, heat and scarce water resources.

Tim Richardson defines a conceptual garden as a landscape designed using a single overriding concept: "Conceptualist landscapes are predicated on ideas rather than plants or the architectural use of hard materials. Such spaces are underpinned by a single concept, or visual motif, which informs every aspect of the design." Many conceptual gardeners use no plants, some only artificial materials. Others design what appear to be more conventional gardens, with plants and hardscaping, but the design is controlled with strict intellectual discipline.

Mr. Richardson is a very good writer, and an agile and informed thinker about gardens. I come away from Avant Gardeners feeling disturbed, not quite able to see why many of the conceptual landscapes in this book are not more aptly called outdoor conceptual or installation art. Some choices seem to be arbitrary. Perhaps it doesn't matter and Mr. Richardson's point is just to stir things up.

I can't read his intent but, for me, this is the point of the book: to question the very meaning of the word "garden", to push the borders of our understanding of gardens, and to open up new possibilities. Whatever your reaction to this book, it will make you think about what a garden is. And that’s a service to the culture of gardening throughout the world.


  1. Splendid review laddie..I think you nailed it. The 'garden' for too long had been relegated to some sort of 'genteel' pursuit and had been stuck in a strange 'nether-land' displaying way too many 'nostalgic' (and hides behind that muddled concept 'tradition') and very tired idea's ...Whatever it is Richardson has attempted to 'do' with this book is almost irrelevant ..the most important outcome is of course readers might just see beyond the compost heap and use the brain a wee bit more!!!
    You have missed your calling I think James...Go forth and submit some writing for the wider world of garden media!!! (refreshing stuff)
    Best Wishes
    William Martin

  2. Thanks, William Martin, for the complimentary words.

  3. from the horses mouth i believe a follow up AG type book is to be may well be out already..I have come to loathe my entry in this book for many reasons..the choice of photos... i send them many more interesting shots and also I had been led to believe that the book was to be about artist gardeners rather than the wall to wall High St Landscape architects we see here..I am considering making an outdoor sculpture out of this tome..nail it to a tree perhaps!
    Bracken Boulevard



Related Posts with Thumbnails